Welcome to 2025: A Year of Transformative Mindsets
You’ve likely seen social posts from friends and peers with “Ins and Outs” for the new year. On a personal level, “More time snuggling on the couch with Bibo,” (my dog), is In. “Saying yes to events I don’t want to attend and thus, being away from Bibo,” is Out. (I mean, look at us. How could I resist?)
In all seriousness, as we enter the new year, I’ve gravitated toward mindsets over action-based resolutions for 2025. Personally, I’m looking for more balance and peace in 2025…and less hustle and reactivity. Professionally, I’m also gravitating towards mindsets over checklists.
Evolution in 2025 cannot be achieved with just a to-do list. Meaningful evolution comes with intellectual curiosity: asking questions at every turn and redefining what progress means as the landscape changes. When you change your mindset, you change your organization.
Here are the guiding mindsets CI is focused on for our industry in 2025, paving the way for a year of progress, connection, and sustained impact.
Mindset #1: The Radical Impact of Hospitality
In arts and culture, hospitality means more than a warm smile or a well-trained usher. It should be a philosophy that permeates every aspect of our organizations. In a world steeped with distractions, genuine hospitality sets our industry apart. It’s about making every human who walks through our doors feel valued, seen, and embraced by something greater than themselves.
But in reality, hospitality starts before a patron walks through our door. It starts with our first interaction with them, which is often digital and relies on how we communicate with them—the tone of our emails, the ease of our websites, the accessibility of our ticketing systems, and so on. It also doesn’t end when the curtain falls. Follow-up emails, personalized acknowledgments, and exclusive invitations to return are critical elements of creating a culture of welcome.
In 2025, hospitality must be redefined as an active, ongoing dialogue between organizations and audiences. It’s not just about inviting people in; it’s about creating spaces—both physical and digital—that make people feel they belong. It’s about fostering relationships that transcend transactions, leaving a lasting impression that inspires loyalty and advocacy.
“Hospitality isn’t just about inviting people in; it’s about creating spaces—both physical and digital—that make people feel they belong.”
If you attended Boot Camp in the fall, you learned about hospitality from Lindsey Peckham, formerly of Eleven Madison Park, and Cookie Ruiz of Ballet Austin. You can learn more about hospitality at Ballet Austin through Cookie’s appearance on the CI to Eye podcast.
Bringing in and retaining audiences in arts and culture has never been more important, and one of the keys to doing that in 2025 is through genuine hospitality.
Mindset #2: Center Audiences and Their “Whys”
Last year at INBOUND, I was introduced (by Sam Jacobs, CEO of Pavillion) to the Bowtie Model. This model has entirely transformed my perspective of building and engaging audiences today.
The model examines the potential for customer-driven growth inside of an organization. There is so much the model offers to how we think about centering the audience experience across their journey with our organization.
Adapted for the arts, the Bowtie Model challenges us to think beyond ticket sales. Take a look at the model here:
The left side of the Bowtie—audience acquisition (or the marketing funnel)—has long been the focal point for many organizations. Marketing dollars are poured into awareness campaigns and outreach efforts to bring new patrons through our doors. But what happens once they arrive?
The right side of the Bowtie—audience retention—is where our industry’s true opportunity lies today. This is where the magic of a single performance has the potential to become a recurring experience (impact) in someone’s life. We can transform casual visitors into lifelong advocates by centering on their “why”—why they chose to engage, why they felt moved, and why they might return.
“We can transform casual visitors into lifelong advocates by centering on their “why”—why they chose to engage, why they felt moved, and why they might return.”
In 2025, it’s critical to consider these pillars of audience retention:
Exceptional On-Site Experiences
From the moment they arrive, how do we eliminate friction and elevate joy for our audiences? Every touchpoint—from the ease of parking to a curated post-show thank you video, like Ballet Austin sends—should be designed with care and attention to detail.
Personalized Follow-Ups
Exclusive Access
Community-Building
In 2025, we must embrace both halves of the Bowtie to make sure our audiences feel the impact of the arts long after they’ve left our spaces.
Mindset #3: Discernment = Progress
Every digital decision should be guided by your organization’s unique point of access. What’s achievable today? What’s aspirational for tomorrow? These answers are unique to you. Iterative optimization and incremental progress can only be defined by you.
In 2025, the following focus areas will be at the top of our minds, but your point of access is unique to you. Discern where you want to go next for each.
Leveraging Artificial Intelligence
How can AI free up resources, giving you more time to focus on what matters most: connecting with your audiences?
Artificial intelligence is here, and it’s transforming industries. Let’s make ours one of them. AI has the potential to streamline operations, enhance audience segmentation, make your organization more discoverable on the SERP, and even serve as a creative partner for content and concepts.Think of AI as a tool to help you work smarter. 52% of marketers in the United States say that AI’s leading benefit is increased speed and efficiency. Where can it bring the most value to you?
Feeding the Modern Content Machine
Are you well-equipped to tell your story effectively and frequently across your marketing channels?
In the age of digital media, content is currency. (Did you know video content accounts for over 80% of all internet traffic?) To stay relevant, we must consistently produce high-quality, algorithmically relevant, and engaging content. This includes promoting our programming AND our brand/mission across email, organic and paid social, and many more. This is a HUGE ask for teams of any size in 2025. How are you staying inspired and strategic?
Segmentation and Audience Development
Are you using data to develop nuanced, strategic messaging for different audience segments?
Understanding your audience is the key to meaningful engagement. Segmentation shows our understanding through tailored messages and experiences to specific groups. According to Hubspot, segmented emails drive 30% more opens and 50% more clickthroughs than unsegmented ones.
As for audience development, keeping audiences engaged and organizations financially healthy can feel like an uphill battle of balance. I recently talked with arts leader and author Aubrey Bergauer about new ways organizations can connect with audiences—we shared in insightful conversation that can guide the year ahead:
- Audience churn is more than an artistic challenge—it’s an operational one. If programming tweaks aren’t moving the needle for you, the time has come to rethink the full audience experience.
- Before upselling your audience to a subscription or donation, focus on getting them back just one more time. Small, consistent actions lead to lasting loyalty.
- In the arts, we’re wired to aim for perfection, both on stage and in the office. But when it comes to change management, research says the opposite: start small, test, refine, repeat.
Data Hygiene
Are you maintaining data integrity?
Clean, accurate data is the foundation of any effective digital strategy, from measuring campaigns to website optimization to your CRM Data. Inaccurate or outdated information can lead to botched decision-making, wasted money and resources, and missed opportunities. As my colleague Yosaif Cohain (CI’s VP, Analytics) has said, “Avoid making decisions based on the H.I.P.P.O (HIghest Paid Person’s Opinion). Decisions should be made with data—and that can’t be done unless you have data you can trust.”
Here are some easy wins for keeping your CRM data clean:
- Tag new leads in your system. Use these tags to segment communications and measure the effectiveness of your digital strategy.
- Establish good naming conventions. Be consistent across CRM lists and email campaigns. This will help you get to the data you want quickly and easily.
- Consider how long audiences should stay on your list. This is something you can decide within your organization. If users don’t engage over a certain period, try sending them a re-engagement email asking if they still want to receive messages.
Benchmarking Progress
How are you measuring your digital efforts and striving for continuous improvement?
Clear metrics and benchmarks are the key to measuring success and identifying areas for growth. Industry benchmarks offer valuable insights to set realistic goals and track progress. Last year, we released the inaugural edition of our digital benchmark study, Cultural Compass, which examines campaign data and focuses on the metrics we’re asked about most. Perhaps it offers some thought starters on areas of focus and improvement in 2025.
Looking Ahead: Your Passion is Your Power
As we step into 2025 (are we really only halfway through January?!),
our solace in this work must be our why.
The arts have the power to:
- Change our perspectives
- Inspire our minds
- Challenge our norms
- Transform our world
Passion for this industry is our greatest strength.
Together, let’s make 2025 a year of great possibility, progress, and profound impact.